Review Policies


1. General Information

1.1. Peer Review Process & Decision Authority

All submitted manuscripts are subject to double-blind peer review by at least two expert reviewers appointed by the Editor-in-Chief. Acceptance is generally contingent upon the approval of both reviewers. If both reviewers recommend acceptance (as-is or with minor revisions), the Editorial Board evaluates the manuscript’s fit within the scope of the journal (language universality, language typology, artificial languages, etc.). The Editor-in-Chief makes the final editorial decision and notifies the author, typically within 8 weeks of submission. In cases of significant disagreement between reviewers, an additional external review will be solicited.

1.2. Desk Rejection

A manuscript may be rejected out-of-hand (desk reject) prior to peer review if the quality of English is insufficient for comprehension or if it contains substantial untranslated text in languages other than English. Language editing is not provided as part of the peer review process.

2. Review Criteria

Reviewers shall evaluate manuscripts based on the following criteria:

2.1. Pertinence of Theme

The manuscript must address language universality, language typology, artificial languages, or communication and culture in language usage from cross-linguistic, typological, social, cultural, historical, philosophical, or political perspectives. Submissions in general linguistics or related fields are considered only if they explicitly draw clear implications for these core themes while maintaining a focus on universal language and its role in human communication.

2.2. Overall Quality and Scientific Originality

The manuscript must present original, creative research that has not been published elsewhere. Reviewers will assess the rigor of the literature review and the contribution of the findings to the field.

2.3. Clarity and Validity of Arguments

Arguments and analyses must be logically sound, rigorously supported, and methodologically trustworthy. Reported results must align with the methodology. Quantitative studies must clearly explain all variable metrics, while qualitative studies must explicitly demonstrate how conclusions are derived from data.

2.4. Appropriateness of Research Methodology

The research design, data sources, sampling methods, and analytical procedures must be appropriate for the research questions. Authors must clearly describe data collection methods and demonstrate data reliability.

2.5. Organization and Structure

Manuscripts must be concise, well-structured, and clearly written. The title should accurately describe the work; the abstract must summarize key content; the introduction must clearly state the problem and objectives; results must be logically presented; and the conclusion must explain the manuscript's contribution to scientific knowledge.

3. Review Process & Workflow

3.1. Initial Processing & Anonymization

Upon receipt of an electronic submission, the Editor-in-Chief classifies the manuscript and assigns two qualified reviewers. The manuscript undergoes a double-blind peer review process, in which reviewers are provided with the anonymized manuscript along with the Review Criteria and evaluation forms.

3.2. Evaluation Categories

Reviewers must evaluate the assigned manuscript under one of four recommendations:

  • Accept without revisions
  • Accept with minor revisions
  • Resubmit after major revisions
  • Reject
3.3. Review Report Submission

Reviewers complete their evaluation and return the report, including specific ratings, constructive comments, and justification to the Editor-in-Chief.

3.4. Minor Revisions Procedure

When minor revisions are recommended, reviewers must provide clear, specific guidance for revision. Authors are typically granted 1-2 week(s) to resubmit the following files:

  • Response to Reviewers: A detailed point-by-point response addressing all comments from reviewers and editors.
  • Revised Manuscript (Marked-up Copy): A version showing all changes made (e.g., using Microsoft Word "Track Changes").
  • Revised Manuscript (Clean Copy): A clean version incorporating all changes without markings.
3.5. Major Revisions Procedure

A manuscript evaluated as "Resubmit after major revisions" must be revised and resubmitted for an additional round of peer review for a subsequent issue. The resubmitted manuscript undergoes the same formal evaluation procedure stipulated herein.

3.6. Final Notification

The Editor-in-Chief notifies the author(s) of the final decision and provides copies of the review reports (and annotated manuscripts, if applicable). The overall review process is normally completed within 8 weeks of submission.

4. Appeal Policy

Authors who wish to appeal an editorial decision must submit a formal letter of appeal to the Editor-in-Chief (unish@sejong.ac.kr) within 7 days of receiving the decision notice.

  • Appeal Requirements: The letter must not exceed two pages (PDF or Word format) and must clearly specify the exact factual or procedural error made during the review process, supported by conclusive evidence.
  • Determination: The Editor-in-Chief will review the appeal and render a final decision. If the appeal is accepted, the manuscript will be re-evaluated or granted conditional acceptance. If rejected, the decision is final, and no further appeals will be accepted for that manuscript.



Online Submission


Submit a New Manuscript!

If you want to submit your Manuscript to us, submit at the Online System now.




Browse Articles


September, 2026
Vol. 27, No. 2

eISSN:2508-5344





Editorial Office

Tel: +82-2-3408-3335
E-mail: unish@sejong.ac.kr