Editorial Workflow
1. Initial Processing & Anonymization
- Desk Review: The Editor-in-Chief classifies the submission and assigns two reviewers.
- Double-Anonymous Review: All author details are removed before manuscript delivery.
2. Evaluation Categories
Reviewers recommend one of four decisions:
- Accept without revisions
- Accept with minor revisions
- Resubmit after major revisions
- Reject
3. Review Report Submission
- Reviewers submit their detailed evaluation, constructive feedback, and justification to the Editor-in-Chief.
4. Minor Revisions Procedure
- Deadline: 1-2 weeks.
- Required Files:
- Response to Reviewers: A point-by-point response letter.
- Revised Manuscript (Marked-up Copy): A tracked-changes version.
- Revised Manuscript (Clean Copy): The final revised version.
5. Major Revisions Procedure
Requires substantial revision and a full re-evaluation round for a subsequent issue.
6. Final Notification
- The Editor-in-Chief sends the final decision with review reports.
- Target Timeline: Completed within 8 weeks of initial submission.
7. Appeal Policy
- Deadline: Submit within 7 days of the decision notice to unish@sejong.ac.kr.
- Submission Requirements: A formal letter (maximum 2 pages) specifying factual or procedural errors with supporting evidence.
- Outcome: The Editor-in-Chief reviews the request to decide whether to allow a re-evaluation or maintain the final rejection (no further appeals are permitted within the current term).












